| Mother Theodore Guerin, SP |
1840-1856 |
| Mother Mary Cecilia Bailly, SP |
1856-1868 |
| Mother Anastasie Brown, SP |
1868-1874 |
| Mother Mary Ephrem Glenn, SP |
1874-1883 |
| Mother Euphrasie Hinkle, SP |
1883-1889 |
| Mother Mary Cleophas Foley, SP |
1890-1926 |
| Mother Mary Raphael Slattery, SP |
1926-1938 |
| Mother Mary Bernard Laughlin, SP |
1938-1948 |
| Mother Marie Helene Franey, SP |
1949-1953 |
| Francis Joseph Elbreg, SP |
1954-1960 |
| Marie Perpetua Hayes, SP |
1960-1968 |
| Jeanne Knoerle, SP |
1968-1983 |
| Barbara Doherty, SP |
1984-1998 |
| Joan Lescinski, CSJ |
1998-2007 |
| David G. Behrs |
2007-2010 |
| Dottie L. King |
2010 - present |
